Metabolism, immune visibility and chordoma immune escape
Agent report for Kya, 15 September 2026, written after her partner asked two questions in em-research: "do tumours become more identifiable to the immune system when switching metabolism?" and "why isn't the patient's immune system attacking the tumour successfully?" Working frame: probable clival chordoma, chondrosarcoma the main imaging lookalike, dedifferentiated and poorly differentiated (INI1-deficient) subtypes still on the list, no histology yet, 51 kg, on morphine, gabapentin and diclofenac, currently eating a high-fat low-carbohydrate diet. Every PMID here was verified through NCBI E-utilities on 15 September 2026, abstract opened and read. No survival or prognosis figures for the patient, by rule. Whether a metabolic switch makes the tumour more aggressive is a separate thread (25) and is not covered here. Brachyury vaccines, the checkpoint review, and opioids and NK cells are in thread 24 and are cited rather than repeated.
Evidence levels. L1 randomised trial, meta-analysis or guideline. L2 prospective human study. L3 retrospective human series. L4 case report or very small series. L5 animal or cell work (stated as in vivo or in vitro), and expert reasoning.
Tier A. The two answers, in plain English
Question A: do tumours become more identifiable to the immune system when they switch metabolism?
Mostly the opposite. Metabolic switching is one of the main ways tumours hide, not a way they get seen. The literature is large, it is almost entirely mouse and cell work, and it runs in one dominant direction: a tumour that is eating hard changes the chemistry of the space around it, and every one of those changes is bad for T cells and NK cells. It eats the glucose they need (Chang 2015, Ho 2015), it floods the space with lactic acid which shuts off their interferon production (Brand 2016), it creates hypoxia and then adenosine, which is a direct off-switch on T cells (Ohta 2006, Hatfield 2015), and it fills the space with lipids that poison the T cells that do get in while feeding the regulatory T cells that suppress them (Manzo 2020, Xu 2021, Wang 2020).
Worse for the specific hope in her partner's question: starving a tumour cell has been shown to make it less visible, not more. Combined oxygen and glucose deprivation stops cancer cells responding to interferon gamma, which is the signal the immune system uses to order a cell to put its antigens on display, and MHC class I presentation falls even with interferon present (Marijt 2019). The same stresses push up HLA-E, a non-classical molecule that actively tells CD8 T cells to stand down (Sasaki 2016).
There are two honest exceptions, and they are worth knowing. First, one 2025 in vitro study found the opposite: prolonged glucose deprivation in melanoma cells lowered EZH2, which lifted a brake on the MHC class I machinery, raised antigen display and increased T cell killing (Edmondson 2025). So the direction is not universal; it depends on the cell and the duration. Second, and more interesting for her, the fuel a ketogenic diet produces is good for her own T cells: beta-hydroxybutyrate is a preferred fuel for CD8 effector T cells and raises their cytokine production and killing (Luda 2023), and in mice a ketogenic diet or oral 3-hydroxybutyrate restored the effect of PD-1 blockade that had failed on a normal diet (Ferrere 2021). A mouse glioma study found a ketogenic diet acted as an immune adjuvant, with more tumour-reactive CD8 and NK activity and less inhibitory receptor expression (Lussier 2016).
The distinction that matters: those last three papers are about the diet helping her immune cells, not about the tumour becoming more identifiable. Nothing in them shows the tumour displaying more antigen. And there is no human trial of any of this in any cancer, let alone chordoma. So the answer to the question as asked is: no, switching metabolism is not a route to making this tumour visible, and the idea of starving it into the open is not supported. If the diet does anything immunological at all, it is on her side of the fight, not the tumour's, and that is a mouse finding.
Question B: why is her immune system not attacking it successfully?
Six reasons, and they stack. This tumour is close to the hardest case in oncology for the immune system.
- There is almost nothing to see. Chordoma carries very few mutations, so it makes very few of the abnormal proteins (neoantigens) the immune system recognises as foreign (Tarpey 2017, Zhang 2026). Its one magnificent marker, brachyury, is a self protein from her own embryonic development, so her T cells were trained not to attack it. That is exactly why the brachyury vaccine idea is so attractive and why the randomised trial of it was negative (thread 24).
- The shop window is broken. Chordoma tumours have defects in the HLA class I antigen presentation machinery (Patel 2021, 24 tumours), and in a 126-patient sarcoma survey the transporter TAP2 was specifically altered in chordoma (Renne 2024). Deletions of 9p and 10q also silence the cGAS-STING alarm pathway (Zhang 2026). A cell that cannot display its antigens cannot be killed by a T cell however many T cells arrive.
- The immune cells are physically kept out. Chordoma is now described as an "immune-excluded" tumour: dense fibrous septa and cancer-associated fibroblast matrix hold T cells in the stroma, with CXCL12 anchoring them there and TGF-beta suppressing them (Zhang 2026). Single-cell plus spatial work on 35 chordomas found immune cells clustered significantly more in the fibrous septa than in the tumour regions themselves (Arrieta 2026). This is the myxoid matrix her partner has read about, and there is real human data behind the idea.
- The ones that get in are switched off. Macrophages dominate the chordoma microenvironment, largely M2-polarised (Dridi 2021, Arrieta 2026), CD8 T cells inside show an exhausted phenotype with restricted clonality (Arrieta 2026), and regulatory T cells and PD-1-positive T cells track with worse outcomes (Zou 2019).
- Immunoediting plus slow growth. The standard framework is elimination, equilibrium, escape (Schreiber 2011), and the equilibrium state has been demonstrated experimentally: transformed cells held in check by adaptive immunity for long periods, unedited, until they escape and grow out (Koebel 2007, mouse in vivo). A slow tumour gives the immune system almost nothing to react to and gives itself years to edit out anything visible. This is the most likely explanation for the shape of the patient's own history: 12 to 14 months of pain, an earlier head MRI reported as clear while she was symptomatic, and a 3.8 cm mass now.
- Possibly the site and the lineage, but this one is speculation. The nucleus pulposus, the adult remnant of the notochord that chordoma comes from, is a classically immune-privileged tissue and its cells express Fas ligand, which kills invading T cells (Takada 2002, rat and human immunohistochemistry). Nobody has shown that chordoma inherits this, and it should be labelled as a hypothesis. Note also what is not true: the clivus is bone outside the dura, so blood-brain-barrier and brain immune privilege arguments do not apply to it.
And the important qualifier: her immune system is not doing nothing, and chordoma is not unconditionally invisible. In one paediatric poorly differentiated (INI1-deficient) chordoma, nivolumab produced a clinical and radiographic response, and a dominant T cell receptor clone recognising a brachyury peptide on MHC was found in the tumour (Williamson 2021). In another INI1-negative case, an EZH2 inhibitor followed by radiotherapy produced a response at untreated distant sites, with CD8 T cells flooding in (Gounder 2019). Both are single patients, both are the SMARCB1-deficient subtype, and that subtype is on the patient's differential. So the honest answer to her partner is: her immune system is losing for six structural reasons, but this tumour family is not beyond being seen, and which version she has changes that answer.
Tier B. Question A in detail: metabolism and immune visibility, both directions
B1. The case that a metabolic switch makes a tumour LESS visible
Glucose competition. The tumour eats the T cells' food. Chang 2015 (Cell, PMID 26321679, L5, mouse sarcoma in vivo) showed that glucose consumption by tumours metabolically restricts tumour-infiltrating T cells, lowering their mTOR activity, glycolytic capacity and interferon gamma production, and that this alone allows tumour progression. Forcing an otherwise immune-controlled "regressor" tumour to be more glycolytic was enough to override T cell control. The same paper showed checkpoint antibodies (anti-CTLA-4, anti-PD-1, anti-PD-L1) partly work by restoring glucose in the microenvironment.
Ho 2015 (Cell, PMID 26321681, L5, mouse melanoma) is the companion: a glucose-poor tumour microenvironment limits T cell glycolysis, and the glycolytic metabolite phosphoenolpyruvate is the specific checkpoint, sustaining calcium-NFAT signalling. Engineering T cells to make more of it restricted tumour growth in mice.
Lactic acid. The waste product is the weapon. Brand 2016 (Cell Metab, PMID 27641098, L5, mouse melanoma in vivo with a human database correlation) showed that melanomas engineered to make less lactic acid grew significantly more slowly and drew in more interferon-gamma-producing T and NK cells, and that this advantage vanished in mice lacking lymphocytes and NK cells or lacking interferon gamma, proving the effect was immune-mediated. Pathophysiological lactic acid concentrations blocked NFAT upregulation in both T and NK cells. In human melanoma datasets, LDHA expression correlated negatively with T cell activation markers.
Hypoxia and adenosine. The off-switch. Ohta 2006 (PNAS, PMID 16916931, L5, mouse in vivo) showed that deleting the A2A adenosine receptor in the host led to rejection of established immunogenic tumours in roughly 60 per cent of mice versus none of the wild-type controls, and that A2A antagonists (caffeine among them) improved tumour control by antitumour T cells. The authors framed this as the explanation for the old paradox of tumours coexisting with antitumour immune cells. Hatfield 2015 (Sci Transl Med, PMID 25739764, L5, mouse in vivo) showed the reverse manoeuvre works: breathing supplemental oxygen reduced intratumoral hypoxia and adenosine, improved CD8 infiltration, weakened regulatory T cell suppression and improved tumour regression, entirely dependent on T and NK cells. Hypoxia also directly disarms NK cells, which lose the ability to upregulate their activating receptors NKp46, NKp30, NKp44 and NKG2D (Balsamo 2013, Eur J Immunol, PMID 23913266, L5 in vitro, human NK cells). This matters for a hypoxic, matrix-dense tumour and it is relevant to thread 22's hyperbaric oxygen question.
Fat. A lipid-rich microenvironment poisons the killers and feeds the suppressors. Manzo 2020 (J Exp Med, PMID 32491160, L5, mouse and human pancreatic tumours) found CD8 T cells inside lipid-rich tumours progressively accumulate long-chain fatty acids which, rather than fuelling them, impair mitochondrial function and reprogramme them away from fat oxidation; restoring the enzyme VLCAD improved T cell persistence in vivo. Xu 2021 (Immunity, PMID 34102100, L5, mouse in vivo) showed the scavenger receptor CD36 takes oxidised lipids into tumour-infiltrating CD8 T cells, causing lipid peroxidation and dysfunction, and that CD36-deficient T cells kept their effector function. Wang 2020 (Nat Immunol, PMID 32066953, L5, mouse in vivo) showed the mirror image: intratumoral regulatory T cells upregulate CD36 to adapt to a lactic-acid-rich environment, and deleting it selectively starved them and suppressed tumour growth. Herber 2010 (Nat Med, PMID 20622859, L5) established the same principle for dendritic cells: lipid accumulation makes them dysfunctional antigen presenters.
This is the part of the literature that deserves a flag given the current food plan. It is mouse and cell work about lipids inside the tumour, and there is no evidence that eating more fat raises intratumoral lipid content in a person or changes any of this. But it is the reason the fat-immunity story cannot simply be told as good news.
OXPHOS-high tumours and resistance to PD-1. Najjar 2019 (JCI Insight, PMID 30721155, L5 with a prospective human correlative component) is the paper her partner's question implies. Patient-derived melanoma lines varied widely in metabolic derangement; deranged oxidative, not glycolytic, metabolism was associated with generating more hypoxia in vivo. Murine melanoma lines with high oxygen consumption drove more T cell exhaustion and less immune activity, and the lines lacking oxidative metabolism were the only ones that responded to anti-PD-1. In prospectively analysed patient samples, oxidative but not glycolytic metabolism was associated with progression on PD-1 blockade. Read across to the patient with care: this is the metabolic direction a tumour moves in when it starts burning fat and ketones rather than glucose, and in melanoma that direction was associated with worse immune control and worse checkpoint response. It is one paper, in one disease, and there is nothing equivalent in chordoma.
Metabolic stress directly shuts down antigen display. This is the most direct answer to the question and it goes the wrong way. Marijt 2019 (J Immunother Cancer, PMID 31196219, L5 in vitro, mouse TC1 and B16F10 lines) deprived tumour cells of oxygen and glucose to mimic a solid tumour interior. MHC class I antigen presentation fell, even in the presence of interferon gamma, because STAT1 failed to be phosphorylated, so the tumour cell became deaf to the immune system's main "display your antigens" order. Forcing active STAT1 rescued presentation fully, and PI3K inhibitors restored both the signalling and recognition by CD8 T cells. Sasaki 2016 (Eur J Immunol, PMID 26711740, L5 in vitro) found that hypoxia or glucose deprivation quantitatively reduced classical MHC class I peptide production and simultaneously increased HLA-E (Qa-1 in mouse), which engages the inhibitory NKG2A/CD94 receptor on activated CD8 T cells and attenuated their response.
B2. The case that a metabolic switch makes a tumour MORE visible
One in vitro paper, and it is specific. Edmondson 2025 (iScience, PMID 40546964, L5 in vitro, human melanoma) found that prolonged glucose deprivation reduced EZH2 and therefore H3K27me3 at MHC class I regulatory genes, raising MHC class I expression and increasing CD8 T cell killing. The authors propose EZH2 inhibition as an immunotherapy adjuvant. Note the resonance with chordoma: the EZH2 inhibitor tazemetostat plus radiotherapy produced exactly this kind of immune activation in an INI1-negative chordoma patient (Gounder 2019). So the "metabolic stress raises antigen display" mechanism exists, it runs through EZH2, and in this tumour family there is already a drug that hits that node without needing a diet to do it.
[Correction 7 Oct 2026: tazemetostat was withdrawn from all markets in March 2026 (Ipsen, after SYMPHONY-1 showed second blood cancers in 5.7% vs 0); trials and compassionate access stopped. PMID 42599162; research 12 A3. Read anything above or below about it as history, not an option.]
The ketone arm, which is about her T cells and not about the tumour. Luda 2023 (Immunity, PMID 37516105, L5, mouse in vitro and in vivo) identified ketone bodies, beta-hydroxybutyrate and acetoacetate, as essential fuels for CD8 effector T cells: beta-hydroxybutyrate directly increased their cytokine production and cytolytic activity, CD8 effector cells preferentially used ketones over glucose to run the TCA cycle both in vitro and in vivo, and ketone oxidation was required for their response to bacterial infection and tumour challenge. Mechanism: beta-hydroxybutyrate was the major source of acetyl-CoA and acted through histone acetylation. Ferrere 2021 (JCI Insight, PMID 33320838, L5, mouse in vivo) showed a ketogenic diet, or 3-hydroxybutyrate alone, produced T-cell-dependent tumour growth retardation, and in settings where anti-PD-1 with or without anti-CTLA-4 had failed, the diet or the ketone restored the response. Adding sucrose (which stops ketogenesis) or blocking the ketone receptor GPR109A abolished the effect. Mechanistically 3-hydroxybutyrate prevented PD-L1 upregulation on myeloid cells and expanded CXCR3-positive T cells. Lussier 2016 (BMC Cancer, PMID 27178315, L5, GL261 intracranial mouse glioma) found mice on a ketogenic diet had more tumour-reactive CD8 and NK cytokine production and cytolysis, more CD4 infiltration, unchanged regulatory T cell numbers, and reduced inhibitory receptor and ligand expression; the authors describe the diet as a possible immune adjuvant.
How to hold these together honestly. The ketone papers are the best pro-diet immunological evidence that exists and they are all mice and cells. They say her T cells can run on ketones and may work better on them. They do not say the tumour becomes more identifiable. And they sit directly against thread 24's finding that chondrosarcoma cells switch on ketolysis under nutrient deprivation and use ketones for proliferation, and that glioblastoma progressed through a ketogenic diet in mice. Same fuel, both sides of the fight. Nobody has measured which side wins in a person, in this disease. This is not a reason to go stricter on the diet, and not a reason to abandon it. Calories first, as agreed, still stands.
Tier C. Question B in detail: the chordoma immune landscape, verified
C1. How little there is to see
- Driver landscape. 104 sporadic chordomas: brachyury (T) duplications in up to 27 per cent, PI3K pathway mutations in 16 per cent, inactivating LYST mutations in 10 per cent (Tarpey 2017, Nat Commun, PMID 29026114, L3). A short list of mostly structural events, not the mutational storm that generates neoantigens.
- Targeted sequencing at scale. The AACR Project GENIE chordoma analysis confirms recurrent SWI/SNF (SETD2, PBRM1, ARID1A), TERT promoter and CDKN2A events, with CDKN2A/B deletions enriched in metastatic tumours and distinct paediatric profiles (Hsia 2025, Cancers, PMID 39941902, L3). Tumour mutational burden was analysed but the abstract gives no figure, so no number is quoted here.
- Low burden as a stated obstacle. The 2026 review of the chordoma tumour immune microenvironment states low tumour mutational burden plainly as one of the intrinsic reasons for the immune-excluded phenotype, alongside CDKN2A/B and PBRM1 loss and cGAS-STING silencing from co-occurring 9p and 10q deletions (Zhang 2026, BBA Rev Cancer, PMID 41448553, review).
C2. HLA class I and the antigen presentation machinery
- Patel 2021 (Clin Orthop Relat Res, PMID 33273248, L3, 24 chordoma tumours from Massachusetts General Hospital, immunohistochemistry against HLA class I antigen processing machinery components). The paper's own framing is the point: it asked whether chordoma cells express HLA class I at all, and its title states the finding, defective HLA class I expression, alongside the patterns of lymphocyte infiltration. Precise per-component percentages are in the full text, not the abstract, and are not quoted here.
- Renne 2024 (Cancer Immunol Immunother, PMID 39249578, L3, 126 patients across 8 bone and soft tissue sarcoma types, tissue microarrays mapping 11 areas per case). All sarcomas studied had some antigen processing machinery defect. The MHC class I transporter TAP2 was specifically altered in chordoma (and in undifferentiated pleomorphic sarcoma and GIST). Heterogeneity was present at patient level and between areas of the same tumour, with high-grade areas differing from high-lymphocyte areas.
That combination, few neoantigens plus a defective display system, is the core of the answer to her partner's question. Even a perfectly primed T cell needs the tumour cell to hold up the antigen.
C3. Checkpoint molecules: the picture is real but the numbers disagree by method
- Dridi 2021 (Cancers, PMID 34283048, L3, 81 chordomas, immunohistochemistry). Macrophages and CD4 cells were the most prominent infiltrating populations, then CD8 T cells; CD20 B cells and high endothelial venules were less frequent. PD-L1 (22C3) was expressed by inflammatory cells in 21 of 81 (26 per cent) and associated with larger tumour size. None of the 81 cases showed PD-L1 expression by tumour cells. PD-L1-positive immune cells were the only immune factor retaining independent prognostic significance, and in the adverse direction.
- Mathios 2015 (J Neurooncol, PMID 25349132, L5 plus small L3; three chordoma cell lines U-CH1, U-CH2, JHC7 plus tissue from 10 patients). PD-1 ligands were not constitutively expressed by chordoma cells but were induced by pro-inflammatory cytokines in every line. In tissue, PD-1 was on tumour-infiltrating lymphocytes in 3 of 6 assessable cases, and PD-L1 was found on infiltrating macrophages and lymphocytes rather than on tumour cells. Erratum PMID 27161248.
- Xia 2021 (Front Immunol, PMID 35145510, L3, 92 spinal chordomas, multiplexed quantitative immunofluorescence) found the opposite on tumour cells: tumour PD-L1 positive in 86 per cent and HHLA2 in 80 per cent, with B7-H3, IDO-1 and Galectin-9 positive on tumour cells in only 21 per cent (mostly stromal). Tumoral HHLA2 and stromal B7-H3 tracked with an aggressive phenotype, more PD-1-positive T cells and fewer CD8 T cells, while stromal PD-L1 and Galectin-9 tracked the other way.
- Be honest about that discrepancy. Nought per cent versus 86 per cent tumour cell PD-L1 is not a small disagreement. The plausible explanations are the assay (22C3 chromogenic immunohistochemistry versus quantitative immunofluorescence), the scoring threshold, and the site (Dridi's series is skull base and sacrum, Xia's is spinal). The practical consequence is that a PD-L1 result on the patient's biopsy will be method-dependent and should not be treated as a hard yes or no.
- B7-H3. In 45 skull base chordomas, B7-H3 was positive in 7 (16 per cent), with the hierarchy B7-H3 > HER3 > PD-L1 > HER2 = VISTA = B7-H4; B7-H3-directed CAR-T cells killed antigen-positive chordoma cells in vitro (Long 2021, Front Oncol, PMID 34868903, L3 plus L5). Later work combined B7-H3 CAR-T with irradiation against radiation-resistant chordoma cells (Wang 2025, J Immunother Cancer, PMID 39848690, L5). CAR-T is a laboratory programme in this disease, not a treatment.
- CTLA-4. In 32 spinal chordomas versus 14 nucleus pulposus controls, CTLA-4 was positive in tumour cells and in all tumour-infiltrating lymphocytes, at a markedly higher rate than normal nucleus pulposus, and higher tumour CTLA-4 predicted worse disease-free and overall survival (He 2020, Clin Transl Oncol, PMID 32504188, L3).
C4. Lymphocytes, macrophages and the physical barrier
- Immune cells are present in every chordoma, and their arrangement predicts outcome. In 54 spinal chordomas, infiltrates were present in all samples; the composite Immunoscore was an independent favourable prognostic factor for local recurrence-free and overall survival, while PD-1-positive and Foxp3-positive (regulatory) T cell densities tracked in the adverse direction (Zou 2019, Neurosurgery, PMID 30032257, L3; survival figures deliberately omitted here).
- The stroma is the barrier and it is measurable. In the same cohort, tumour-stroma ratio correlated with stromal PD-L1, Immunoscore and CD3 and CD4 T cell density, and inversely with microvessel density, Ki-67, muscle invasion and Foxp3 and PD-1 T cell counts; low tumour-stroma ratio independently predicted worse local recurrence-free and overall survival (Zou 2019, Neurosurgery, PMID 31501892, L3).
- The strongest modern description: immune-excluded, with the septa as the action. Integrated single-cell RNA sequencing, T cell receptor profiling and multiplex immunofluorescence on 35 chordoma samples plus six paired tumour and blood samples (Arrieta 2026, Neuro Oncol, PMID 41586579, L3). Chordomas ranged from highly infiltrated to immune desert. Tumour-associated macrophages dominated and were enriched for antigen-processing pathways. T cell receptor profiling showed clonal overlap between tumour and peripheral T cells, meaning there is a systemic anti-tumour response happening. Exhausted CD8 T cells showed restricted clonality and tumour-specific motifs. Spatially, immune cell clustering was significantly higher in the fibrous septa than in tumour regions.
- Mechanism of the exclusion. Cancer-associated fibroblasts build extracellular matrix barriers and secrete CXCL12 that anchors T cells in the stroma; TGF-beta suppresses cytotoxic function and infiltration; M2-polarised macrophages and regulatory T cells drive effector exhaustion; the septa act as hubs for myeloid and T cell interaction rather than as simple walls (Zhang 2026, PMID 41448553, review).
- Recurrence shifts the landscape further against her. Single-cell and receptor sequencing of primary versus recurrent skull base chordoma: antigen-presenting cancer-associated fibroblasts and antigen-presentation-high dendritic cells were enriched in primary tumours; recurrent tumours had fewer plasma cells and fewer B cell receptor clonotypes, and FN1 (fibronectin 1) was upregulated and more secreted (Huo 2023, Clin Transl Med, PMID 37784253, L3 plus L5 validation). Reading across: the immune position is better at first presentation than after recurrence, which is an argument for definitive treatment now rather than later, made on immunological grounds as well as surgical ones.
C5. Immunoediting, and why a slow tumour can grow for years under surveillance
The framework is elimination, equilibrium and escape: immunity destroys some cancers, holds others in check, and selects the survivors for reduced immunogenicity, so the tumour that finally appears clinically is the one that has already been sculpted to be invisible (Schreiber 2011, Science, PMID 21436444, review). The middle state is not just theory. Koebel 2007 (Nature, PMID 18026089, L5, mouse primary chemical carcinogenesis in vivo) demonstrated equilibrium directly: neoplastic cells held by adaptive immunity, transformed but proliferating poorly in vivo, remaining unedited while restrained, and becoming edited only when they spontaneously escaped and grew into clinically apparent tumours.
Applied to the patient, as reasoning and not as data (L5). A tumour with a handful of drivers, a self-protein lineage marker, defective antigen display and a dense matrix is the archetype of a tumour that spends years in equilibrium or slow escape. It also fits the timeline in the master file: trigeminal-distribution pain for 12 to 14 months, a head MRI reported as clear roughly 10 months before admission while she was already symptomatic, ptosis from July and diplopia from late August. The immune system's failure here is not an acute collapse and there is no reason to look for one. It is a slow structural mismatch, and nothing she or her partner did caused it.
C6. Does checkpoint blockade do anything in chordoma? Sometimes, in the salvage setting
- Bishop 2022 (J Immunother, PMID 35943386, L3, 17 patients with recurrent progressing chordoma, mostly pembrolizumab, median 8 cycles). 15 of 17 (88 per cent) had clinical benefit: 1 complete response, 3 partial responses, 11 stable disease; median duration of response 12 months among responders. Two patients had grade 3 or 4 immune toxicity (colitis, myocarditis). The authors argue for integration as first-line systemic therapy; that is a conclusion from a 17-patient retrospective review with obvious selection bias and it should be read as such.
- Fazel 2025 (Cancer, PMID 40911493, L3, IMPRESARC, 272 advanced sarcoma patients across six French centres). Overall response rate 17 per cent, disease control 49 per cent, and chordoma is named among the histotypes showing better outcomes alongside alveolar soft part sarcoma, SMARCA4-deficient tumours, GIST and NF1-mutant disease. Worse outcomes with poorer performance status and high neutrophil-to-lymphocyte ratio.
- The INI1-deficient exceptions. Williamson 2021 (npj Precis Oncol, PMID 34931022, L4, two paediatric poorly differentiated chordomas, whole genome, transcriptome, bisulfite sequencing and multiplex immunohistochemistry): tumour-associated CD8 T cells and PD-L1 present in both; checkpoint inhibitor therapy produced a clinical and radiographic response (CORRECTION 6 Oct 2026, full text read: in ONE of the two; patient 1 died of progressive lung metastases before any immunotherapy; patient 2, a girl with a 4.3 cm C1/clival PDC and lung nodules, after chemo and declined protons, got nivolumab on compassionate access at recurrence: 58% shrinkage at 3 cycles, slow regrowth from best response by cycles 7 to 11, still on it at 14 cycles with excellent function; final outcome not reported; BC Cancer, Vancouver); a dominant T cell receptor clone specific for a brachyury peptide-MHC complex was identified, suggesting the response ran through brachyury recognition. Gounder 2019 (Clin Cancer Res, PMID 30642912, L4, one patient with SMARCB1-deleted metastatic poorly differentiated chordoma): four weeks of tazemetostat in a phase 2 trial, then radiotherapy to the primary at progression, followed by complete response at distant untreated sites (an abscopal effect) lasting more than two years, with on-treatment biopsies showing loss of H3K27 trimethylation and a marked increase in proliferative CD8 T cells, Foxp3 regulatory T cells and PD-1 and LAG-3 expressing immune cells, mostly in the stroma.
- Thread 24 already covers the systematic review of immunotherapy in advanced chordoma (Wang 2022, Cancers, PMID 36612259) and the three brachyury vaccine trials, including the negative randomised GI-6301 study. Nothing found today changes that position. Immunotherapy in chordoma remains a research field, not a treatment, and it is not an alternative to surgery and proton therapy.
C7. Chondrosarcoma, briefly, because it is still on the differential
- Kostine 2016 (Mod Pathol, PMID 27312065, L3, tissue microarrays). PD-L1 expression was absent in conventional (0 of 119), mesenchymal (0 of 19) and clear cell (0 of 20) chondrosarcomas. It was positive in 41 per cent (9 of 22) of dedifferentiated chondrosarcomas, confirmed at 52 per cent (11 of 21) in an independent cohort on whole sections. Expression was found only in the dedifferentiated component, and correlated with high tumour-infiltrating lymphocyte numbers (p = 0.014) and positive HLA class I expression (p = 0.024), but not with overall survival (p = 0.22).
- SARC028 (Tawbi 2017, Lancet Oncol, PMID 28988646, L2, single-arm phase 2, pembrolizumab 200 mg every three weeks). In the bone sarcoma cohort, 2 of 40 responded: 1 of 22 osteosarcoma and 1 of 5 chondrosarcoma. None of 13 Ewing sarcoma. The primary endpoint was not met in either cohort.
- Read across. Conventional chondrosarcoma is immunologically cold in exactly the way conventional chordoma is. The dedifferentiated subtype is the one with an immunotherapy rationale, because it is the one that expresses PD-L1, draws in lymphocytes and keeps HLA class I. This is the same pattern as chordoma, where the INI1-deficient poorly differentiated subtype supplies the only convincing responses. If the patient's histology comes back as either of the aggressive subtypes, the immunotherapy conversation becomes real. If it is conventional chordoma or conventional chondrosarcoma, it does not.
Tier D. What in the patient's current situation plausibly affects her immunity
Ranked by how much evidence there is and how much can be done about it. Everything here is about general immune competence, particularly around surgery. None of it is a treatment for the tumour.
- Being 51 kg and having lost 12 to 15 per cent of her body weight. The biggest item, and the most fixable. Protein-energy malnutrition is the commonest cause of secondary immunodeficiency worldwide (standard teaching, thread 13). The best recent human data: 43 colorectal cancer patients assessed prospectively before resection, in whom malnutrition was associated with more tissue-infiltrating neutrophils and altered T cell phenotypes, including reduced effector cytokine expression in conventional T-helper and iNKT cells inside the tumour (Perillo 2026, Front Nutr, PMID 42317870, L2 prospective pilot). Different cancer, small, and not proof of causation, but it is the only human study here that links the thing she actually has, undernutrition before an operation, to the thing her partner is asking about, anti-tumour T cell function. Calories and protein are the immune intervention with the best evidence in this whole file.
- Opioids. Covered in threads 13 and 24, and not repeated. The short version stands: the NK suppression signal is real, mu-mediated, and most relevant in the perioperative window, and the one large randomised test of the regional-versus-opioid anaesthesia question (Sessler 2019, Lancet, PMID 31645288, L1, 2,108 women) was negative for recurrence. Do not undertreat her pain because of it.
- Pain and stress hormones, which cut the other way from the opioid worry. Catecholamines and prostaglandins released around surgery are implicated in pro-metastatic processes, and in a randomised double-blind placebo-controlled biomarker trial of 34 colorectal cancer patients given propranolol plus etodolac for 20 perioperative days, treated tumours showed reduced epithelial-to-mesenchymal transition and increased tumour-infiltrating CD56 natural killer cells (Haldar 2020, Cancer, PMID 32533792, L1, biomarker endpoints, small; three-year recurrence 2 of 16 versus 6 of 18, p = 0.239, not significant). Separately, gabapentin given before hysterectomy in a 60-patient randomised trial lowered pain scores, plasma cortisol (p < 0.001) and catecholamines (p < 0.05) 24 hours after surgery, with modest shifts in lymphocyte subsets (Karbić 2014, Int Immunopharmacol, PMID 25448495, L1, small). The reframe worth giving her partner: uncontrolled pain is itself an immunosuppressive stressor, so controlling her pain properly is not simply a trade against immunity.
- Sleep. Sleep loss reduces NK activity and vaccine responses and, when chronic, produces low-grade systemic inflammation (Besedovsky 2019, Physiol Rev, PMID 30920354, review; already in thread 13). Free, and currently one of the worse-controlled variables in the house.
- Diclofenac and COX-2. The counter-intuitive one, and it is reassuring. Tumour-derived prostaglandin E2 is immunosuppressive: in mouse melanoma, breast and colorectal models, genetic ablation of cyclooxygenases or prostaglandin E synthases rendered tumours susceptible to immune control and shifted the inflammatory profile toward anti-cancer pathways, and COX inhibition synergised with anti-PD-1 to eradicate tumours; the COX-dependent suppressive signature was conserved in human melanoma biopsies (Zelenay 2015, Cell, PMID 26343581, L5 in vivo). Diclofenac is a non-selective COX inhibitor. So her regular diclofenac sits on the immunologically favourable side of this question, not the unfavourable one. That is mechanism, not evidence of benefit in chordoma, and it is not a reason to change any dose in either direction. It is a reason to stop worrying about that particular drug. (Her diclofenac needs watching for kidneys and bleeding, per the medicine card and thread 13, which is a separate matter.)
- Dexamethasone, if it is started. Iorgulescu 2021 (Clin Cancer Res, PMID 33239433, L5 mouse in vivo plus L3 human) is the sharpest data. In immunocompetent mice with GL261 and CT-2A glioblastoma, concurrent dexamethasone reduced survival on anti-PD-1 in a dose-dependent way, abrogating benefit with or without radiotherapy; dexamethasone reduced T lymphocyte numbers by increasing apoptosis, reduced their functional capacity, and generally reduced myeloid and NK populations. In 181 consecutive IDH wild-type glioblastoma patients treated with PD-(L)1 blockade, baseline dexamethasone was the strongest predictor of poor survival on multivariable adjustment, with a hazard ratio of 2.16 even below 2 mg. What this does and does not mean: it is not a reason to refuse dexamethasone if she needs it for oedema or for cranial nerve function, and steroids around skull base surgery are standard. It is a strong reason to ask for the lowest effective dose, the shortest course, and a written taper.
- What has no evidence either way. Morphine's effect on the specific mechanisms in this file (antigen presentation, T cell exclusion) is unstudied. Gabapentin has no cancer-immunity literature. Neither is a reason to change anything.
Tier E. What this means for the patient this week
The honest headline for her partner, in one paragraph. There is no way to make this tumour more visible by changing what the patient eats, and the published mechanisms mostly run the other way: metabolic stress on a tumour cell tends to shut its antigen display down, not open it up. Her immune system is not failing through weakness or through anything that was neglected. It is facing a tumour with almost no foreign-looking proteins, a damaged display system, and a wall of matrix that holds T cells in the stroma, and that combination has been measured in human chordoma tissue by several independent groups. The two things in the house that genuinely bear on her immune competence are her weight and her sleep, and the things that bear on it most are what happens around the operation. The one variable that could change the whole immunotherapy conversation is the histology, and specifically the INI1 stain.
No change to the food plan on the strength of this file. Calories and protein first, as thread 24 concluded. The pro-diet immune evidence (ketones fuel CD8 T cells, ketones restored PD-1 responses in mice) is real but it is mouse and cell work about her T cells, not about tumour visibility, and it is offset by the ketolysis findings in thread 24. Nothing here justifies going stricter, and nothing here justifies stopping.
Questions worth putting to the surgeon on Wednesday (17 September). Four of these are additions to the consultation sheet; the rest are already there in some form.
- At biopsy, alongside brachyury, INI1/SMARCB1, TP53, p16 and Ki-67, can the pathologist also run PD-L1 and an HLA class I or MHC class I stain, and can enough tissue be banked fresh frozen for sequencing? Reason to give them: the only chordoma patients with convincing checkpoint inhibitor responses in the literature are INI1-deficient, and PD-L1 plus HLA class I status is what any future immunotherapy discussion would be built on. Ask them to note where in the tumour the sample came from, because antigen presentation defects vary between areas of the same tumour (Renne 2024).
- If PD-L1 is reported, which assay and which threshold? Worth asking because tumour cell PD-L1 in chordoma has been reported at 0 per cent by one method and 86 per cent by another, so a bare positive or negative is not interpretable on its own.
- If the histology is dedifferentiated chondrosarcoma, will the immune markers be assessed on the dedifferentiated component specifically? That is the only chondrosarcoma subtype with PD-L1 expression, lymphocyte infiltration and retained HLA class I, and the expression was found exclusively in the dedifferentiated part.
- If dexamethasone is started, what is the lowest effective dose, and can we have the planned duration and taper in writing? The immunological cost of steroids is dose-dependent and measurable, and the ask is for the minimum that controls her symptoms, not for avoidance.
- Can we have the dietitian referral and a target weight this week? Frame it as the immune and surgical-recovery item it is, not as a lifestyle question. Ask for her weight to be recorded at the clinic and for the number to be given to her partner.
- Is there any research immune-profiling or tissue-banking study her sample could contribute to? Chordoma immune profiling is active (Arrieta 2026 and others) and the national MDT or the Chordoma Foundation route is the natural way to ask. This costs her nothing and is worth one sentence.
- Already on the sheet and not to be dropped: the perioperative pain plan and the written opioid taper agreed before the operation, not after (thread 24 and the 14 September log). Nothing in this file changes that priority; if anything, the stress-hormone data strengthens the case for good analgesia rather than weakening it.
Sources
Verified through NCBI E-utilities on 15 September 2026; abstract opened for each. Level in brackets.
Metabolism and immune visibility, against (tumour becomes less visible)
- Chang CH and colleagues. Metabolic competition in the tumor microenvironment is a driver of cancer progression. Cell 2015;162:1229. PMID 26321679. [L5, mouse sarcoma in vivo]
- Ho PC and colleagues. Phosphoenolpyruvate is a metabolic checkpoint of anti-tumor T cell responses. Cell 2015;162:1217. PMID 26321681. [L5, mouse melanoma]
- Brand A and colleagues. LDHA-associated lactic acid production blunts tumor immunosurveillance by T and NK cells. Cell Metab 2016;24:657. PMID 27641098. [L5, mouse in vivo plus human dataset correlation]
- Ohta A and colleagues. A2A adenosine receptor protects tumors from antitumor T cells. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 2006. PMID 16916931. [L5, mouse in vivo]
- Hatfield SM and colleagues. Immunological mechanisms of the antitumor effects of supplemental oxygenation. Sci Transl Med 2015. PMID 25739764. [L5, mouse in vivo]
- Balsamo M and colleagues. Hypoxia downregulates the expression of activating receptors involved in NK-cell-mediated target cell killing without affecting ADCC. Eur J Immunol 2013. PMID 23913266. [L5, human NK cells in vitro]
- Manzo T and colleagues. Accumulation of long-chain fatty acids in the tumor microenvironment drives dysfunction in intrapancreatic CD8+ T cells. J Exp Med 2020. PMID 32491160. [L5, mouse and human tissue]
- Xu S and colleagues. Uptake of oxidized lipids by the scavenger receptor CD36 promotes lipid peroxidation and dysfunction in CD8+ T cells in tumors. Immunity 2021. PMID 34102100. [L5, mouse in vivo]
- Wang H and colleagues. CD36-mediated metabolic adaptation supports regulatory T cell survival and function in tumors. Nat Immunol 2020. PMID 32066953. [L5, mouse in vivo]
- Herber DL and colleagues. Lipid accumulation and dendritic cell dysfunction in cancer. Nat Med 2010. PMID 20622859. [L5]
- Najjar YG and colleagues. Tumor cell oxidative metabolism as a barrier to PD-1 blockade immunotherapy in melanoma. JCI Insight 2019. PMID 30721155. [L5 with prospective human correlative component]
- Marijt KA and colleagues. Metabolic stress in cancer cells induces immune escape through a PI3K-dependent blockade of IFN-gamma receptor signaling. J Immunother Cancer 2019;7:152. PMID 31196219. [L5, in vitro]
- Sasaki T and colleagues. Microenvironmental stresses induce HLA-E/Qa-1 surface expression and thereby reduce CD8+ T-cell recognition of stressed cells. Eur J Immunol 2016. PMID 26711740. [L5, in vitro]
Metabolism and immune visibility, for (more visible, or better T cells)
- Edmondson JL and colleagues. EZH2 loss during metabolic stress drives restoration of MHC class I machinery in melanoma. iScience 2025. PMID 40546964. [L5, in vitro]
- Luda KM and colleagues. Ketolysis drives CD8+ T cell effector function through effects on histone acetylation. Immunity 2023. PMID 37516105. [L5, mouse in vitro and in vivo]
- Ferrere G and colleagues. Ketogenic diet and ketone bodies enhance the anticancer effects of PD-1 blockade. JCI Insight 2021. PMID 33320838. [L5, mouse in vivo]
- Lussier DM and colleagues. Enhanced immunity in a mouse model of malignant glioma is mediated by a therapeutic ketogenic diet. BMC Cancer 2016;16:310. PMID 27178315. [L5, mouse in vivo]
Immunoediting framework
- Schreiber RD, Old LJ, Smyth MJ. Cancer immunoediting: integrating immunity's roles in cancer suppression and promotion. Science 2011. PMID 21436444. [review]
- Koebel CM and colleagues. Adaptive immunity maintains occult cancer in an equilibrium state. Nature 2007. PMID 18026089. [L5, mouse in vivo]
Chordoma immune landscape
- Zhang H and colleagues. Targeting the tumor immune microenvironment in chordoma: from mechanistic insights to therapeutic breakthroughs. Biochim Biophys Acta Rev Cancer 2026. PMID 41448553. [review]
- Arrieta VA and colleagues. Integrated immune profiling of chordomas reveals spatially organized niches and functional heterogeneity. Neuro Oncol 2026. PMID 41586579. [L3, 35 samples, scRNA-seq, TCR, multiplex immunofluorescence]
- Dridi M and colleagues. The immune microenvironment of chordomas: an immunohistochemical analysis. Cancers 2021. PMID 34283048. [L3, 81 tumours]
- Mathios D and colleagues. PD-1, PD-L1, PD-L2 expression in the chordoma microenvironment. J Neurooncol 2015. PMID 25349132 (erratum PMID 27161248). [L5 plus small L3, 3 cell lines, 10 patients]
- Xia C and colleagues. Coexpression of HHLA2 and PD-L1 on tumor cells independently predicts the survival of spinal chordoma patients. Front Immunol 2021. PMID 35145510. [L3, 92 samples, quantitative immunofluorescence]
- Long C and colleagues. B7-H3 as a target for CAR-T cell therapy in skull base chordoma. Front Oncol 2021. PMID 34868903. [L3, 45 samples, plus L5 CAR-T in vitro]
- Wang K and colleagues. B7-H3 CAR-T cell therapy combined with irradiation is effective in targeting bulk and radiation-resistant chordoma cancer cells. J Immunother Cancer 2025. PMID 39848690. [L5]
- He G and colleagues. CTLA-4 expression in chordoma and tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes predicts prognosis of spinal chordoma. Clin Transl Oncol 2020. PMID 32504188. [L3, 32 tumours]
- Zou MX and colleagues. Clinical impact of the immune microenvironment in spinal chordoma: Immunoscore as an independent favorable prognostic factor. Neurosurgery 2019. PMID 30032257. [L3, 54 tumours]
- Zou MX and colleagues. The relationship between tumor-stroma ratio, the immune microenvironment, and survival in patients with spinal chordoma. Neurosurgery 2019. PMID 31501892. [L3, 54 tumours]
- Huo X and colleagues. Unravelling the role of immune cells and FN1 in the recurrence and therapeutic process of skull base chordoma. Clin Transl Med 2023. PMID 37784253. [L3 plus L5]
- Patel SS and colleagues. Defective HLA class I expression and patterns of lymphocyte infiltration in chordoma tumors. Clin Orthop Relat Res 2021. PMID 33273248. [L3, 24 tumours]
- Renne SL and colleagues. Disruptions in antigen processing and presentation machinery on sarcoma. Cancer Immunol Immunother 2024. PMID 39249578. [L3, 126 patients, 8 sarcoma types including chordoma]
- Tarpey PS and colleagues. The driver landscape of sporadic chordoma. Nat Commun 2017. PMID 29026114. [L3, 104 cases]
- Hsia B and colleagues. Genomic characterization of chordoma: insights from the AACR Project GENIE database. Cancers 2025. PMID 39941902. [L3]
- Takada T and colleagues. Fas ligand exists on intervertebral disc cells: a potential molecular mechanism for immune privilege of the disc. Spine 2002. PMID 12131712. [L5, rat and human immunohistochemistry]
Checkpoint blockade in chordoma and chondrosarcoma
- Bishop AJ and colleagues. Immune checkpoint inhibitors have clinical activity in patients with recurrent chordoma. J Immunother 2022. PMID 35943386. [L3, 17 patients]
- Fazel M and colleagues. Clinical and biological factors associated with response to immune checkpoint inhibitors in advanced sarcomas: IMPRESARC. Cancer 2025. PMID 40911493. [L3, 272 patients]
- Williamson LM and colleagues. Clinical response to nivolumab in an INI1-deficient pediatric chordoma correlates with immunogenic recognition of brachyury. npj Precis Oncol 2021. PMID 34931022. [L4, 2 patients]
- Gounder MM and colleagues. Immunologic correlates of the abscopal effect in a SMARCB1/INI1-negative poorly differentiated chordoma after EZH2 inhibition and radiotherapy. Clin Cancer Res 2019. PMID 30642912. [L4, 1 patient]
- Kostine M and colleagues. Analysis of PD-L1, T-cell infiltrate and HLA expression in chondrosarcoma indicates potential for response to immunotherapy specifically in the dedifferentiated subtype. Mod Pathol 2016. PMID 27312065. [L3]
- Tawbi HA and colleagues. Pembrolizumab in advanced soft-tissue sarcoma and bone sarcoma (SARC028). Lancet Oncol 2017. PMID 28988646. [L2, single-arm phase 2]
- Chordoma immunotherapy systematic review and the three brachyury vaccine trials: thread 24 (Wang 2022 PMID 36612259; DeMaria 2021 PMID 33594772; Heery 2015 PMID 26130065; Cote 2024 PMID 38985843).
the patient's own situation
- Perillo F and colleagues. Preoperative malnutrition is associated with suppressed intratumoral T cell function and distinct tumor-associated microbiota in colorectal cancer: a prospective pilot study. Front Nutr 2026. PMID 42317870. [L2, 43 patients]
- Haldar R and colleagues. Perioperative COX2 and beta-adrenergic blockade improves biomarkers of tumor metastasis, immunity, and inflammation in colorectal cancer: a randomized controlled trial. Cancer 2020. PMID 32533792. [L1, 34 patients, biomarker endpoints]
- Karbić VO and colleagues. Gabapentin-induced changes of plasma cortisol level and immune status in hysterectomized women. Int Immunopharmacol 2014. PMID 25448495. [L1, 60 patients]
- Zelenay S and colleagues. Cyclooxygenase-dependent tumor growth through evasion of immunity. Cell 2015. PMID 26343581. [L5, mouse in vivo, human signature]
- Iorgulescu JB and colleagues. Concurrent dexamethasone limits the clinical benefit of immune checkpoint blockade in glioblastoma. Clin Cancer Res 2021. PMID 33239433. [L5 mouse in vivo plus L3, 181 patients]
- Besedovsky L, Lange T, Haack M. The sleep-immune crosstalk in health and disease. Physiol Rev 2019;99:1325. PMID 30920354. [review; thread 13]
- Opioids, NK cells and the perioperative window, including Sessler 2019 (Lancet, PMID 31645288, L1): threads 13 and 24.
- Ketone utilisation by chondrosarcoma and glioblastoma, ERGO2, and the brachyury vaccine trials: thread 24. Chordoma metabolism and subtypes: threads 16 and 21.
Deliberately not quoted here: survival and prognosis figures from the chordoma and sarcoma series above, per the standing rule; the per-component HLA class I percentages from Patel 2021 and the tumour mutational burden figure from Hsia 2025, because neither appears in the abstract and the full texts were not read.